iRubric: Journal Article Review rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Journal Article Review Journal Article Review Rubric Code: P7B635 By Sisterteach Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Education Type: Writing Grade Levels: Undergraduate

Journal Article Review
	Good 100 pts	Fair 80 pts	Poor 60 pts
Summary for Article 30 pts Summarize the main ideas and facts in the article.	Good All main ideas and facts from the article are included. Summary is written in objective view and referencing to the article is provided. Author and source are named.	Fair Some details from article are missing. Summary is not objective OR minimal referencing to the article is provided. Author OR source are not named.	Poor No summary is provided OR a verbatim of the text is provided. Author and source are not named.
Conclusions 20 pts Provide personal comments pertaining to the article and how it relates to class material and the textbook.	Good Personal comments are clearly stated. Student clearly demonstrates a strong working knowledge of class material relative to the article. References are made to the textbook and specific chapters or page numbers are provided.	Fair Few personal comments. Student demonstrates some working knowledge of class material relative to the article. Few references are made to the textbook OR no chapter or page number information is provided.	Poor No personal comments are provided. No relationship between article and class material is provided. No references are given.
Grammar and Organization 20 pts	Good Paper is well organized and easy to follow. There are no spelling, grammar, or punctuation errors.	Fair Paper is not well organized OR there are many grammatical errors.	Poor Paper is not organized and there are many grammatical errors.
Mechanics 20 pts	Good Paper is the appropriate length, has appropriate margins, and is provided in the correct font.	Fair Paper is not the appropriate length OR has inappropriate margins OR is not in the correct font.	Poor Paper is not the appropriate length, has inapproriate margins, and is not in the correct font.
Reference in APA Format 5 pts	Good Reference is provided in the correct APA format.	Fair Reference is provided in the correct format with few mistakes.	Poor Reference is not provided in the correct format.
Presentation 5 pts	Good Related to topic of article and engaging. Incorporates examples that can be applied to classroom instruction.	Fair Is related to topic of article. Presentation not engaging OR does not incorporate examples that can be applied to classroom instruction.	Poor Is not related to topic of article. Presentation not engaging OR does not incorporate examples that can be applied to classroom instruction.