iRubric: Journal Article Review rubric

All main ideas and facts from the article are included. Summary is written in objective view and referencing to the article is provided. Author and source are named.

5 pts

Some details from article are missing. Summary is not objective OR minimal referencing to the article is provided. Author OR source are not named.

3 pts

No summary is provided OR a verbatim of the text is provided. Author and source are not named.

1 pts

Personal comments are clearly stated. Student clearly demonstrates a strong working knowledge of class material relative to the article. Reflections are made about the impact to the business world

5 pts

Few personal comments. Student demonstrates some working knowledge of class material relative to the article. Little reflection is given about the impact to the business world.

3 pts

No personal comments are provided. No relationship between article and class material is provided. No reflection given about impact to the business world.

1 pts

Paper is well organized and easy to follow. There are no spelling, grammar, or punctuation errors.

5 pts

Paper is not well organized OR there are many grammatical errors.

3 pts

Paper is not organized and there are many grammatical errors

1 pts

Paper is the appropriate length and article is attached to the document.

5 pts

Paper is not the appropriate length OR is missing attached document.

3 pts

Paper is not the appropriate length and article is not attached to the document.

1 pts

Reference is provided in the correct APA format

5 pts

Reference is provided in the correct format with few mistakes.

3 pts

Reference is not provided in the correct format.

1 pts