iRubric: Reflection Paper Rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Reflection Paper Rubric Reflection Paper Rubric Rubric Code: E24986A By Klechman Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Education Type: (Other) Grade Levels: Undergraduate, Graduate, Post Graduate

Reflection Paper Rubric
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 3 pts	Good 4 pts	Excellent 5 pts
Reading Completion Responsiveness to assigned reading(s)	Poor Response reflects no evidence of completing the readings - off-topic.	Fair Although response is on topic, it does not explicitly reflect the readings -- it could have been written without completing the tasks.	Good Somewhat unclear that the readings were understood or not all readings explicitly included.	Excellent Very clear that all assigned readings were understood by incorporation into reaction.
Personalization Exploration of personal reactions	Poor Shows minimal awareness of personal reactions, focusing solely on intellectualized reactions.	Fair Identifies personal reactions, but demonstrates little exploration or understanding of these reactions; avoids discomfort and uncertainty.	Good Discusses personal reactions, including exploration of the basis for these reactions (e.g., recognizes new perspectives about WDE).	Excellent Deeply explores personal reactions, including exploration of the basis for these reactions (e.g., articulates insights into own cultural rules and biases); willingness to sit with uncertainty and not seek easy answers.
Application Application of readings to personal and professional self	Poor No mention of implications of the tasks for student's personal or professional attitudes and/or behaviors.	Fair Implications of the tasks for personal / professional attitudes / behaviors minimal or perfunctory.	Good Student addresses implications of the tasks for personal / professional attitudes and/or behaviors.	Excellent Student identifies and discusses implications of the tasks for personal / professional attitudes and/or behaviors in a complex way.
Proofreading	Poor Response contains so many typographical and grammatical errors as to be difficult to read.	Fair Response contains a distracting level of typographical and/or grammatical errors.	Good Response contains minimal typographical and/or grammatical errors.	Excellent Response contains nearly zero typographical and/or grammatical errors.
Overall Score	Poor Poor Poor selected for multiple sections	Fair Fair Multipole sections are fair or poor	Good Good Multiple selections are good or excellent	Excellent Excellent 3 of 4 sections are excellent