Skip to main content

iRubric: Argument and Analysis Essay rubric

find rubric

edit   print   share   Copy to my rubrics   Bookmark   test run   assess...   delete   Do more...
Argument and Analysis Essay 
Rubric Code: X243XAW
Ready to use
Public Rubric
Subject: English  
Type: Writing  
Grade Levels: 9-12

Powered by iRubric Argument and Analysis Essay
  Poor

(N/A)

Fair

(N/A)

Good

(N/A)

Excellent

(N/A)

Introduction and Thesis
15 pts

Poor

- Lacks focus and direction as to what the main argument will be
- Does not include any hook or background information
- Main idea is unclear to the reader
- Thesis is not placed as the last sentence of the paragraph
- Little to none of the elements of a thesis are evident
Fair

- Somewhat lacks focus and direction as to what the main argument will be
- Does not include a strong hook or is missing background information
- Main idea is slightly unclear to the reader
- Thesis is not placed as the last sentence of the paragraph
- Some elements of a thesis are evident
Good

- Mostly focus and exemplifies direction as to what the main argument will be
- Includes a hook and has background information that are of importance to the paper
- Main idea is mostly clear to the reader
- Thesis is the last sentence of the paragraph
- Almost all elements of a thesis are evident
Excellent

- Precise and focused and exemplifies direction as to what the main argument will be
- Includes a strong hook and has background information that are of importance to the paper
- Main idea is clear to the reader
- Thesis is the last sentence of the paragraph
- All elements of a thesis are evident
Body Paragraph #1
15 pts

Poor

-Does not include any point supporting thesis
-Does not link back to the thesis or leaves the reader confused as to why the reasoning is important to the paper
Fair

-Points are within the body paragraph but are unclear and confusing to the reader, questioning if it relates the the thesis
-Provides little evidence to back up the claim
-Attempts to link back to the thesis and may leave the reader confused as to why the reasoning is important to the paper
Good

-Points are mostly clear to the reader and provides some evidence to the claim
- Somewhat links back to the thesis or leaves the reader slightly confused as to why this is important to the paper
Excellent

Points are clear and precise, relating back to thesis and the reading is left with zero confusion
-Provides clear evidence that supports that claim and argument to the paper
-Has a strong link back to the thesis and explains to the reader why this is important to the paper
Body Paragraph #2
15 pts

Poor

-Does not include any point supporting thesis
-Does not link back to the thesis or leaves the reader confused as to why the reasoning is important to the paper
Fair

-Points are within the body paragraph but are unclear and confusing to the reader, questioning if it relates the the thesis
-Provides little evidence to back up the claim
-Attempts to link back to the thesis and may leave the reader confused as to why the reasoning is important to the paper
Good

-Points are mostly clear to the reader and provides some evidence to the claim
- Somewhat links back to the thesis or leaves the reader slightly confused as to why this is important to the paper
Excellent

-Points and clear and precise, relating back to thesis and the reading is left with zero confusion
-Provides clear evidence that supports that claim and argument to the paper
-Has a strong link back to the thesis and explains to the reader why this is important to the paper
Body Paragraph #3
15 pts

Poor

-Does not include any point supporting thesis
-Does not link back to the thesis or leaves the reader confused as to why the reasoning is important to the paper
Fair

-Points are within the body paragraph but are unclear and confusing to the reader, questioning if it relates the the thesis
-Provides little evidence to back up the claim
-Attempts to link back to the thesis and may leave the reader confused as to why the reasoning is important to the paper
Good

-Points are mostly clear to the reader and provides some evidence to the claim
- Somewhat links back to the thesis or leaves the reader slightly confused as to why this is important to the paper
Excellent

-Poins and clear and precise, relating back to thesis and the reading is left with zero confusion
-Provides clear evidence that supports that claim and argument to the paper
-Has a strong link back to the thesis and explains to the reader why this is important to the paper
Conclusion
15 pts

Poor

-Does not make any connections supporting the original thesis made in the introduction paragraph
- Does not include any restatement of thesis or points
- Has no closing argument
Fair

-Attempts to make connections supporting the original thesis made in the introduction paragraph
-Does not include any restatement of thesis or points
-Attempts to make a closing argument but does not help the reader understand your purpose
Good

-Makes some connections supporting the original thesis made in the introduction paragraph
- Includes a restatement with parts of thesis or points
- Somewhat makes a closing argument but readers may understand your purpose
Excellent

-Makes clear and precise connections supporting the original thesis made in the introduction paragraph
- Include a restatement of thesis and points
- Includes a strong closing argument to help the reader understand your purpose
MLA Citations and Overall MLA Format
15 pts

Poor

- Did not follow any of the required MLA format needed
- Included almost no in-text citations
- Has no works cited page
Fair

- Did not follow almost any of the required MLA format needed
- Included little in-text citations
- Has a works cited page, but format and MLA requirements are missing
Good

- Followed mostly all of the required MLA format needed
- Included a few in-text citations
- Has a works cited page, but format and MLA requirements have a few errors
Excellent

- Followed all of the required MLA format needed
- Included a multiple in-text citations
- Has a works cited page, and format and MLA requirements have little to no errors
Writing Conventions
10 pts

Poor

- Sentences are incomplete or are unclear to the reader. Paper lacks intent and focus
- Lacks in grammar correctness
Fair

- Some sentences are incomplete or are unclear to the reader. Paper somewhat lacks intent and focus
- Grammar and writing style errors are evident within the paper
Good

- Most of the Sentences are complete and are mostly clear to the reader. Paper is mostly intent and focus
- Some grammatical and writing style errors within the paper
Excellent

- Sentences are complete and are clear to the reader
- Almost zero grammatical and writing style errors within the paper




Subjects:

Types:





Do more with this rubric:

Preview

Preview this rubric.

Edit

Modify this rubric.

Copy

Make a copy of this rubric and begin editing the copy.


Print

Show a printable version of this rubric.

Categorize

Add this rubric to multiple categories.

Bookmark

Bookmark this rubric for future reference.
Assess

Test run

Test this rubric or perform an ad-hoc assessment.

Grade

Build a gradebook to assess students.

Collaborate

Apply this rubric to any object and invite others to assess.
Share

Publish

Link, embed, and showcase your rubrics on your website.

Email

Email this rubric to a friend.

Discuss

Discuss this rubric with other members.
 

Do more with rubrics than ever imagined possible.

Only with iRubrictm.

n178