10 pts
20 pts
25 pts
30 pts
Does the author clearly state his/her position in the thesis towards the end of the introduction? Do you think the writer clearly explains and fully develops the different positions on the issue? Does the author use compelling and insightful evidence and explain each thoroughly? In the explanations for the opposiiton's viewpoints, does the author acknowledge and refute effectively? SCORE:
Is the synthesis clear and easy to follow? Are paragraphs unified around a single topic and cohesive? Is the issue (and the opposing positions) introduced effectively? Is the plan - chunking or comparing - readable with helpful transitions? SCORE:
2 pts
5 pts
15 pts
Are there at least 4 credible, relevant sources that are used effectively? Is MLA Style followed correctly in citations and the Works Cited page?
8 pts
Are there spelling, punctuation, and capitalization errors? Are there grammar errors, such as fragments, run-ons, comma splices, or subject-verb agreement? Do these errors make the writing difficult to understand? Does the paper adhere to teacher guidleines as outlined on the syllabus (e.g. typed, double spaced, font size and type, etc.)? SCORE:
1 pts
4 pts
Does the writer follow the guidelines to use 1 inch margins, double space the essay, and indent 5 spaces for the first line of a new paragraph? (See syllabus for paper submission guidelines)