Does not meet the standard
2 pts
Meets little or minimal criteria.
4 pts
Meets some criteria, is passable.
6 pts
Meets most criteria.
8 pts
Meets or exceeds all criteria. An excellent example.
10 pts
Attractive in appearance, neatly presented, has mass appeal.
Cupcakes are uniform in size and appearance.
Design of cupcake/frosting is creative and visually appealing.
Cupcake has a distinct and pleasing flavor that would appeal to many.
Cupcake is tender with a dense moist crumb. Good feel in the mouth.
Frosting has a distinct and pleasing flavor that compliments the cake.
Frosting is smooth and creamy with smooth texture (unless meant to have texture.) If textured it compliments the cupcake.
There is a balance of cupcake and frosting flavor and texture that is pleasing and flavors blend together well.
Healthy component (reduced sugar, fat, enhanced nutrition - apples, carrots, dark chocolate, lower calorie, etc)