iRubric: Group Case Presentation Rubric

The oral presentation was inarticulate and difficult to follow with poor cohesion between points presented. Presented by only a single member of the group. Poor discussion of questions.

The oral presentation was choppy, difficult to follow with little cohesion between points presented and between members of the group. Some of the members of the group participated in the presentation. Needs more interaction and discussion of questions.

The oral presentation was mostly smooth and seamless with good cohesion between points presented and between members of the group. Most of the members of the group participated in the presentation.
Proficient discussion initiated/ maintained.

The oral presentation was smooth and seamless with excellent cohesion and flow between points and group members. All members of the group participated in the presentation. Exceptional discussion initiated and maintained to facilitate learning.

Weak conclusions. Presentation needs to be more logical and organized.

Group does not understand the case information. Unrealistic solutions.

The group somewhat understands the dynamics, presented some realistic alternatives, objectives, some sound implementation strategies.

The group understands the dynamics, presented realistic alternatives, objectives, sound implementation strategies.

Lack of courtesy, ignoring comments, not following up on audience or panel comments.

More interaction between group members and audience needed.

Good interaction between group members and between group and audience; willingness to listen and follow up on comments.

Excellent interaction between group members and between group and audience. Responsive and courteous, willing to listen, answer questions when able and admit when they cannot answer. Keep discussion flowing and vital. Conclude discussion with thanks for participation.