1 pts
2 pts
3 pts
4 pts
Are there enough reasons that are appropriate, relevant to the category, clear and convincing? Are comparisons used effectively?
Does the essay anticipate and answer alternative judgments and counterarguments?
Is the essay well organized and clear? Is there a strong hook, satisfying end, and if appropriate, an additional design feature to add interest (such as an illustration)?
Is the expression and language mature and engaging?