iRubric: Article Critiques rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Article Critiques Article Critiques These are the guidelines for completing the article critiques. Rubric Code: H24WBB By jamiedawn Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: English Type: Assignment Grade Levels: (none)

Enter rubric title
	Poor 4 pts	Good 6 pts	Excellent 8 pts
Main points	Poor Main points were not clearly identified or key statements were missing from the article. The theme of the article was weakly integrated into the critique.	Good Main points were somewhat identified utilizing some of the key statements from the article. The theme of the article was integrated somewhat into the critique.	Excellent Main points were clearly identified utilizing key statements from the article. The theme of the article was integrated seamlessly into the critique.
Instructional Implications	Poor Few supporting statements are provided that loosely address instructional changes.	Good General, supporting statements are provided that somewhat address instructional changes.	Excellent Detailed, supporting statements are provided that clearly address instructional changes.
Impact on Philosophy	Poor Explains with general, somewhat weak examples how the article confirms or challenges the student's present philosophy regarding phonics instruction.	Good Explains with somewhat general examples how the article confirms or challenges the student's present philosophy regarding phonics instruction.	Excellent Clearly explains with specific examples how the article confirms or challenges the student's present philosophy regarding phonics instruction.
APA Style
	Poor 2 pts	Good 4 pts	Excellent 6 pts
APA Style	Poor There are more than four errors in the writing that pertain to APA style.	Good There are a few errors in the writing that pertain to APA style.	Excellent There are no errors in the writing that pertain to APA style.