iRubric: Hot Air Balloon Formal Presentation & Report rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Hot Air Balloon Formal Presentation & Report STEM Research III Formal Presentation STEM project in a General Chemistry Class during the Unit on Gas Laws. Rubric Code: FX493C5 By emmafettes Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Chemistry Type: Presentation Grade Levels: 9-12

Presentation
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 2 pts	Good 3 pts	Excellent 4 pts
Title/group members	Poor No title	Fair Title only	Good Title with Group Name	Excellent Title with Group Name and members listed
Introduction	Poor Very brief introduction presented. Presenter showed very little knowledge of How Hot Air Balloons work and little knowledge about the Gas Laws.	Fair Brief introduction presented. Presenter showed some knowledge of How Hot Air Balloons did not discuss relationship to the Gas Laws.	Good Brief introduction presented. Presenter showed some knowledge of How Hot Air Balloons work as related to the Gas Laws.	Excellent Brief introduction presented. Presenter showed knowledge of How Hot Air Balloons work as related to the Gas Laws.
Final Design & Calculations	Poor shows very little understanding of the design and the calculations used to determine performance of hot air balloon.	Fair Vague presentation of design chosen and/or incomplete calculations to determine the performance of the hot air balloon. Little understanding of the calculations.	Good Presented in detail design chosen and why, or calculations used to determine performance of hot air balloon. Showed some understanding of the calculations and the design.	Excellent Presented in detail the design chosen and why. Detailed calculations used to help determine performance of hot air balloon. Showed a good understanding of the calculations and design.
Materials/Procedures	Poor No materials list, discussion of procedures.	Fair Incomplete list of materials, no explanation as to why they were chosen. Brief discussion on procedures.	Good List of materials and some discussion on why they were chosen. Little discussion on procedures.	Excellent Detailed list of materials and discussed why they were chosen. Briefly outlined the procedures.
Analysis	Poor Did not show understanding of design and redesign process. Only represented final flight data.	Fair Little understanding of the design and redesign process. Showed some understanding of final flight data.	Good Showed some understanding of the design and redesign process. Showed understanding of final flight data.	Excellent Showed good understanding of the design process and data to support redesign of hot air balloon if needed. Good understanding of final flight data.
Conclusion	Poor Showed very little understanding of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Did not give any ideas of how to make this project better. Did not show understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.	Fair Little explanation of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Any ideas of how to make this project better. Showed little understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.	Good Some explanation of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Any ideas of how to make this project better. Summarized understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.	Excellent Good explanation of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Any ideas of how to make this project better. Summarized understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.
Creativity/Organization/Neatness	Poor Presentation was somewhat organized. Little creativity or audience appeal.	Fair Creative presentation. Some visual aides (photos, videos, etc.) Attractive and neatly presented. Some organization.	Good Creative presentation. Some visual aides (photos, videos, etc.) Attractive and neatly presented. Organized	Excellent Very creative presentation. Nice visual aides (photos, videos, etc.) Nice attractive and neatly presented. Very well organized
Time Management	Poor Presentation had to be stopped and could not be completed.	Fair Presentation ran over or by 2 minute	Good Presentation ran over or under by 1 minute	Excellent Presentation was presented between 4 - 7 minutes
Professionalism	Poor Not nicely dressed or spoke out toward the audience	Fair Nicely dressed or spoke out toward the audience	Good Professional attire and mannerism. Spoke out toward the audience.	Excellent Very professional attire and mannerism. Spoke out toward the audience so that everyone could hear.
Formal Report
	Poor 1 pts	Fair 2 pts	Good 3 pts	Excellent 4 pts
Title Page and Table of Contents	Poor Title page with no names or Table of Contents.	Fair Title with Group Name and members names.	Good Title with Group and members. Incomplete Table of Contents.	Excellent Title with Group Name and members. Table of Content referencing pages for report sections.
Introduction	Poor Not information about the History of the Hot Air Balloon. Some information explaining how the Hot Air Balloon Works.	Fair Little information discussing the History of the Hot Air Balloon. Very little information explaining how the hot air balloon works, not reference to the Gas Laws.	Good Some information discussing the History of the Hot Air Balloon. Some information explaining how a hot air balloon works as related to the Gas Laws.	Excellent Detailed introduction discussing the History of Hot Air Balloons. How hot air balloon work as related to the Gas Laws.
Design & Calculations	Poor Vague drawing of the hot air balloon design chosen and why. No calculations used to help determine performance of hot air balloon.	Fair Vague drawing of the hot air balloon design chosen and why. Few calculations used to help determine performance of hot air balloon.	Good Detailed drawing, with no metric dimensions, of the hot air balloon design chosen and why. Some calculations used to help determine performance of hot air balloon.	Excellent Detailed drawing, with metric dimensions, of the hot air balloon design chosen and why. Detailed calculations used to help determine performance of hot air balloon.
Materials & Procedures	Poor Incomplete list of materials. Unorganized final procedures for design and performance of the Hot Air Balloon. Could not follow procedures for replication.	Fair Incomplete list of materials. Unorganized final procedures for design and performance of the Hot Air Balloon.	Good Incomplete of materials. Final procedures for design and performance of the Hot Air Balloon. Some trouble following procedures for replication	Excellent Detailed list of materials. Detailed final procedures for design and performance of the Hot Air Balloon. Easy to follow to replicate.
Data / Analysis	Poor Incomplete data represented to support design and redesign of the Hot Air Balloon. No tables or diagrams used organize data. Metric system was not used. Unorganized and not easy to understand.	Fair Incomplete data represented to support design and redesign of the Hot Air Balloon. Tables provided but not labeled appropriately. Diagrams provided but not labeled appropriately. Metric system used. Somewhat organized.	Good Data represented to support design and redesign of the Hot Air Balloon. Tables labeled appropriately. Diagrams labeled appropriately. Metric system used. Somewhat organized and easy to understand.	Excellent All data represented to support design and redesign of the Hot Air Balloon. Tables labeled appropriately. Diagrams labeled appropriately. Metric system used. Very organized and easy to understand.
Conclusion	Poor Did not explain performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Vague to no ideas of how to make this project better. Showed little to no understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.	Fair Vague explanation of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Vague ideas of how to make this project better. Showed little understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.	Good Good explanation of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Vague ideas of how to make this project better. Summarized and showed some understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.	Excellent Detailed explanation of performance, how your balloon compared to the other groups, what could be done differently, etc. Any ideas of how to make this project better. Summarized and showed complete understanding of gas laws as they relate to the hot air balloon and your design process.
Work Cited	Poor Incomplete list of references / resources.	Fair Incomplete list of references of resources used to complete your project, with no proper citation format.	Good List of references of resources used to complete your project, using some citation format.	Excellent Detailed list of references of resources used to complete your project, using proper citation format.

Keywords:

Hot Air Balloons, Gas Laws

Subjects:

Chemistry

Types:

Presentation

Discuss this rubric