- Username
- Password
forgot?

iRubric: Book Review rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Book Review Book Review Rubric for Book Review for Journal of Applied Christian Leadership Rubric Code: B7WB4W By pattersstan Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Social Sciences Type: Writing Grade Levels: Graduate

Book Review Rubic
	Excellent (N/A)	Good (N/A)	Satisfactory (N/A)	Marginal (N/A)	Unsatisfactory (N/A)
Overview/Summary	Excellent 14-15 points Excellent understanding of the material	Good 11-13 points Clear understanding of material	Satisfactory 8-10 points Partial understanding of material	Marginal 6-7 Points Questionable completion and/or comprehension of material	Unsatisfactory 0-5 points No evidence of completion and/or concern about material or assignment
Thesis Statement	Excellent 14-15 points Excellent restatement of the author's thesis that clearly integrates reviewer's opinion of whether the thesis was successfully argued or not	Good 11-13 points Restatement of the author's thesis but integration of reviewer's opinion lacks clarity	Satisfactory 8-10 points Restatement of the author's thesis but no integration of reviewer's opinion of whether the thesis was successfully argued or not	Marginal 6-7 Points Rudimentary, ambiguous thesis restatement	Unsatisfactory 0-5 points Absence of a thesis restatement
Review/Critique	Excellent 41-45 points Intelligent arguments throughout paper	Good 37-40 points Sound points and arguments	Satisfactory 31-36 points Well-stated but vague arguments	Marginal 26-30 points Rudimentary, vague arguments	Unsatisfactory 0-25 points Absence of any clear arguments
Organization/Citations	Excellent 14-15 points Well organized with coherent structure and citations entered as end notes	Good 11-13 points May stray at times from analysis to description but citations are entered as end notes	Satisfactory 8-10 points No discernible structure, but central focus of paper still easily understood with some end note citations	Marginal 6-7 points No structure, delivered almost as a "train of thought" and minimal end note citations	Unsatisfactory 0-5 points Sloppy, disoriented manner and no citations
Formatting/grammar/spelling/paging	Excellent 9-10 points Meets all structural requirements: length, margins, font, paging <3 major spelling or grammatical errors	Good 8 points Meets all structural requirements: length, margins, font, paging but has 3-5 major spelling or grammatical errors	Satisfactory 7 points Meets only 2 structural requirements: length, margins, font, paging and has 6 - 10 major spelling or grammatical errors	Marginal 6 points Followed only 1 of the paper requirements and has 11-20 major spelling or grammatical errors	Unsatisfactory 0-5 points Followed 1 or no paper requirements and has 20+ major spelling or grammatical errors