iRubric: Story Music Composition rubric

The music chops and changes seemingly randomly, and has little that the listener can feel comfortable or connected. Too many unrelated layers are creating a sense of confusion

The music has some binding ideas that provide some continuity to the sections. Some layers do not combine well or are not placed appropriately.

The music has layers that work well together, and their positioning has been considered well to match the scenes. Some issues with the texture choices create problems for the listener

The selected layers combine very well, with clarity and appropriateness of texture that they create. There is a sense of unity or logic about the music.

The instrumental part is minimal and does not contribute appropriately to the overall music or action. The notation is difficult to read.

The instrumental part is brief, but compliments the other music well. The notation is readable but missing some expected conventions of notation

The instrumental part is well considered and matches the other music well. The notation is well presented and follows the expected notation conventions.

The instrumental part is well crafted and supports and enhances the other music. The notation is written at a very high standard.

The harmony does not make sense with the melody.

Some of the harmony makes sense with the melody, but there are some poor chord choices and not much creativity.

The chords make sense with the melody but they are too "safe" and not very creative.

The chords compliment the melody beautifully and take just enough risks to make it interesting and musical.