Skip to main content
find rubric
Historical Fiction Short Story Rubric 
This is a rubric determines how well each short story was written.
Rubric Code: A376X6
Draft
Public Rubric
Subject: English  
Type: Writing  
Grade Levels: 9-12

Powered by iRubric Historical Fiction
  Needs Improvement

5 pts

Fair

6 pts

Good

7 pts

Excellent

8 pts

Research

Needs Improvement

Articles are not turned in, or only 1 article is turned in.
Fair

Articles are turned in but include no notes or highlighting of pertinent information
Good

Articles turned in with story, articles are not highlighted or no notes are included
Excellent

Articles are turned in and show highlighting/notes that are to be used in the short story
Pre-Writing & 1st Draft

Needs Improvement

Pre-writing and rough draft not turned in.
Fair

Either rough draft or pre-writing is not complete or does not reflect revision from draft to final copy
Good

Rough draft and pre-writing turned in.
Excellent

Turned in with final copy, reflects development, editing, and revision has occured to produce final copy
Creativity

Needs Improvement

- The story has no creativity or orginality
Fair

- The story has minimal creativity where a reader might want to read on.
Good

- The story reflects a good amount of creativity so that a reader would want to read on.
Excellent

-The story is largely creative and is intriguing to the point that a reader would be very intererested in the outcome.
Details

Needs Improvement

- The story is rarely described with good detail.

- You don't feel like you're in the story at all.
Fair

- The story is somewhat described with detail.

- You somewhat feel like your in the story.
Good

- Most everything is described with detail.

- You sometimes feel like you are in the story.
Excellent

- Everything is described with precise detail.

- You feel like you are watching a movie or you're in the story.
Setting

Needs Improvement

- You do not know where the story takes place, your completely lost.
Fair

- You somewhat know where things are taking place.
Good

- You know where things are taking place most of the time.
Excellent

- You know exactly where everything is taking place.

- The setting is described so well that you feel like you're there.
Historical Details

Needs Improvement

Historical details are scarce and story does not reflect historical details
Fair

Historical details are vague and do not reflect thorough research
Good

Historical details are present, additional historical information could be included
Excellent

Historical details reflect thorough research and understanding of the events taking place during this time in history
Character Description

Needs Improvement

- characters are poorly developed and it is hard to imagine what these characters might be like.
Fair

-Character development needs improvement
Good

- Characters are developed but some characters could be better developed through more direct or indirect characterization.
Excellent

-characters are thoroughly developed through direct and indirect characterization
Development

Needs Improvement

Story development does not exist and does not follow sequence.
Fair

Story development nees to be improved or revised
Good

Story development follows story sequence but some component could be better developed
Excellent

Story contains exposition, rising action, climax, falling action, resolution
Grammar

Needs Improvement

More than 8 errors, please revise
Fair

6-7 errors
Good

4-5 errors
Excellent

Three errors or fewer




Subjects:

Types:



Build free rubrics at www.iRubric.com. Design, share, assess, collaborate. Rubric Code: A376X6